Skip to content
Search
AI Powered
Latest Stories

Experts urge caution over exercise testing study on vapers and smokers

Experts urge caution over exercise testing study on vapers and smokers
Photo: iStock

Experts have cautioned against drawing definitive conclusions from the results of a study that suggested young people who vape perform as poorly as smokers in exercise tests, pointing out several limitations in the research methodology.

The study, presented at the European Respiratory Society Congress 2024 in Vienna, Austria, is still unpublished and not yet peer-reviewed.


Rachel Richardson, manager at the Methods Support Unit at Cochrane, highlighted the need for careful interpretation.

“This is unpublished research, and so independent scientists have not yet scrutinised the methods and the results. Peer review is a crucial part of the scientific process and it is a major concern that these findings are being widely disseminated without this scrutiny,” Richardson said.

Richardson also pointed out that the study shows an association between vaping and reduced exercise performance but does not establish causation. Other factors, such as differences in physical activity levels between the groups, could also play a role in the findings.

Richardson further noted the study’s small sample size and the lack of updated data. While the press release referenced the initial findings, the researchers have since collected data from an additional 15 participants, which will be presented at the conference, being held on 7–11 September.

Professor Kevin McConway, emeritus professor of applied statistics at The Open University, echoed the need for caution, citing the lack of detailed information about the study.

“We have a fairly brief press release and a very brief summary of the work. But the study has not yet been through a full peer review, and important details about what was actually done (or not done) are just not available, not yet anyway,” McConway noted.

McConway also warned against concluding that vaping and smoking have identical effects based on the limited data available.

“The three groups (tobacco smokers, vapers, non-smokers) would have differed in many ways apart from whether they smoked, vaped or did neither. The information we have on the study does give some details, for example of the participants’ ages, heights and weights, and of measures of lung and circulatory system function while resting. But apart from that, we have rather few details on how the groups compared. So it remains possible that the observed differences in response to exercise are actually caused, not by whether they smoke or vape, but by some other difference, perhaps in lifestyle,” McConway noted.

“It could even be that cause and effect goes in a different direction altogether. Maybe some people chose not to use tobacco or vapes because they were more involved in sport and exercise, and it’s this previous involvement in sport that is the cause of their better physiological response to exercise, rather than the fact that they chose not to smoke or vape,” he added.

“Or it could indeed be that the differences in response to exercise are in fact caused by the smoking or vaping. The issue is that we just can’t tell, at any rate on the basis of the information available.”

More for you

Yvette Cooper

Home secretary Yvette Cooper speaking at the annual conference hosted by the NPCC and APCC on 19 November 2024

Photo: GOV.UK

Home secretary pledges to restore neighbourhood policing

Home secretary Yvette Cooper has announced plans to rebuild neighbourhood policing and combat surging shop theft as part of an ambitious programme of reform to policing.

In her first major speech at the annual conference hosted by the National Police Chiefs’ Council and Association of Police and Crime Commissioners on Tuesday, Cooper highlighted four of the key areas for reform: neighbourhood policing, police performance, structures and capabilities, crime prevention.

Keep ReadingShow less
Andrew Bailey acknowledges retailers' warning on job cuts
Bank of England building on Threadneedle Street, CLondon (Photo: iStock)
Getty Images/iStockphoto

Andrew Bailey acknowledges retailers' warning on job cuts

Retailers are right to warn of potential job cuts as a result of tax increases announced at last month’s budget, Bank of England governor Andrew Bailey has said.

Bailey appeared before the cross-party Treasury select committee on Tuesday (19), after almost 80 retailers claimed rising costs would make “job losses inevitable, and higher prices a certainty”.

Keep ReadingShow less
High Street shopping street
Photo: iStock

High Street Rental Auctions: Independent retailers urged to engage with local councils

The British Independent Retailers Association (Bira) has urged independent shop owners to reach out to their local councils about the government's newly announced High Street Rental Auction (HSRA) powers, which aim to tackle persistently vacant commercial properties on UK high streets.

Introduced through the Levelling Up and Regeneration Act 2023, the HSRA legislation will come into force on 2 December. It will give local authorities the ability to put the leases of long-term empty shops up for public auction, allowing businesses and community groups to secure short-term tenancies.

Keep ReadingShow less
Home energy smartmeter
Photo: iStock

Inflation jumps in October on higher energy bills

Britain's annual inflation rate jumped more than expected in October to back above the Bank of England's target as households and businesses faced higher energy bills, official data showed Wednesday.

The Consumer Prices Index reached 2.3 per cent from a three-year low of 1.7 percent in the 12 months to September, the Office for National Statistics said in a statement.

Keep ReadingShow less
Nestle

Nestle logos are pictured in the supermarket of Nestle headquarters in Vevey, Switzerland, February 13, 2020

REUTERS/Pierre Albouy/File Photo

Nestle to step up marketing investment; Waters and beverages to become standalone business

Nestle on Tuesday said it will increase investment in advertising and marketing to 9 per cent of sales by the end of 2025. The company also announced plans to make its waters and premium beverages activities a global standalone business from New Year.

Unveiling a plan to fuel and accelerate growth at a Capital Markets Day for investors and analysts, the Swiss group also said it aims cost savings of at least CHF 2.5 billion (£2.25bn) above existing initiatives by end 2027 to fund increased investments.

Keep ReadingShow less