Skip to content
Search
AI Powered
Latest Stories

Kellogg mounts legal challenge to HFSS regulations

Kellogg mounts legal challenge to HFSS regulations
Photo: iStock
Getty Images

Kellogg has taken the government to court challenging the nutrient model used in the HFSS (high in fat, salt and sugar) products regulations that are set to take effect in October. More significantly, the cereal maker has also challenged legality of the way the regulations are introduced.

The company said it supports the government’s Obesity Strategy, but believes the formula used to measure the nutritional value of food is wrong when it comes to breakfast cereals.


“We believe the formula being used by the government to measure the nutritional value of breakfast cereals is wrong and not implemented legally. It measures cereals dry when they are almost always eaten with milk,” Chris Silcock, Kellogg’s UK managing director, said.

“All of this matters because, unless you take account of the nutritional elements added when cereal is eaten with milk, the full nutritional value of the mealis not measured.”

Kellogg added that a judge has accepted that the case has merit and agreed that it can proceed to the next stage, which is a hearing in court.

The company noted that the Nutrient Profiling Model (NPM) works like a virtual set of scales and calculates the nutritional value of a food by weighing up things like protein and fibre against things like salt and saturated fat.

Kellogg clarified that their concern lies with this formula and its application to breakfast cereals only as it scores cereals based on dry weight and does not take into account of the nutritional elements added when cereal is eaten with milk. In fact, 28.4 per cent of all milk consumed in the UK is with breakfast cereal, it added.

The company said it has tried on a number of occasions to have a discussion with the government on the issue.

“We’ve tried to have a reasonable conversation with the UK government over the past twelve months about making this change, but to no avail,” Silcock said. “So, we now find ourselves doing something which we really didn’t want to have to do which is to go to court to get the formula changed so that it reflects how people eat our food in real life.”

Kellogg further alleged that the way that the government is now proposing to use the NPM is for a purpose for which it was not intended.

“It was originally conceived in 2004/05 to determine whether certain products could be advertised on television pre-9pm. It is now being used in a very different way, and in a way for which it was never intended – to determine where things can bepositioned in a supermarket or the placement of advertising on things like YouTube or social media,” the company said in a statement.

Kellogg said its application for the judicial review was approved on three grounds, the argument around how the NPM value is calculated for breakfast cereal, plus two additional legal arguments which cover how the new regulations were written into law.

These argue that there is no legal basis in the Food Safety Act of 1990 for the enforcement regime introduced by the government in the regulations and that the parliament was not given the opportunity to properly scrutinise the NPM and its application because it is included in a technical guidance document and not in the actual legislation.

“We believe that it’s right that the parliament has the opportunity to properly assess the policy the government is proposing, which is why we also raised the two additional legal points in addition to the main argument,” the company said.

New rules will restrict the placement of HFSS food and drink in stores and promotion of those goods by retailers from October.

Products considered less healthy cannot be featured in key store locations, such as checkouts, entrances, aisle ends and their online equivalents.

Stores will also have to restrict volume price promotions such as "buy one get one free" or "3 for 2" offers on so-called HFSS products.

The Department of Health and Social Care (DHSC) said it could not comment on the Kellogg's case but defended the new rules.

"Obesity costs the NHS more than £6 billion a year and is the second biggest cause of cancer in the UK," said a DHSC spokesperson.

"Breakfast cereals contribute 7 per cent to the average daily free sugar intakes of children. Restricting the promotion and advertising of less healthy foods is an important part of the cross-government strategy to halve childhood obesity by 2030, prevent harmful diseases and improve healthy life expectancy."

More for you

Mary Glindon

Mary Glindon

Labour MP cautions proposed vaping tax could hinder smoking cessation efforts

Labour MP Mary Glindon has cautioned that a new excise tax on vaping could discourage smokers from switching to less harmful alternatives.

Glindon, who also chairs the All-Party Parliamentary Group for Responsible Vaping, said the chancellor’s proposed tax, which will add £2.20 per 10ml of vaping liquid when it goes into effect on October 1, 2026, will “hurt working people”, who rely on vapes to quit smoking.

Keep ReadingShow less
Liverpool c-store license revoked after grave accusations

iStock image

Liverpool c-store license revoked after grave accusations

The alcohol license of Liverpool convenience store, which had become the “go to” location for illicit sales, has been revoked after a 13-year-old girl had to be taken to hospital after getting drunk on vodka she had purchased unchallenged from the store.

According to local media reports, members of Liverpool Council’s licensing and gambling sub-committee have taken a dim view of the levels of “wholesale breaches and criminal offences” at Old Swan Express on Prescot Road, stripping owner Sinnathamby Arumugasamy of his licence, despite him only gaining permission to trade at the former angling store in February of this year.

Keep ReadingShow less
Minor dip in footfall ahead of Golden Quarter
Hollie Adams/Getty Images
Getty Images

Minor dip in footfall ahead of Golden Quarter

October’s footfall figures declined marginally as compared to last year, shows latest industry data, highlighting concerns for a policy environment that supports growth and investment.

According to data by British Retail Consortium (BRC), total UK footfall decreased by 1.1 per cent in October (YoY), down from +3.3 per cent in September. High Street footfall decreased by 3.6 per cent in October (YoY), down from +0.9 per cent in September.

Keep ReadingShow less
SPAR supports spooktacular activity at Preston primary school

SPAR supports spooktacular activity at Preston primary school

Children at Ashton Primary School in Preston got into the spirit of Halloween with some spooktacular support from SPAR.

Thirty children in Reception class took part in a cookery session to concoct a healthy pumpkin and carrot soup with ingredients supplied by James Hall & Co. Ltd. SPAR recipe cards were also provided to children to take home alongside additional pumpkins, carrots, and onions, enabling them to recreate their bubbling broth together with their parents.

Keep ReadingShow less
Kepak Group acquires Summit Foods to expand convenience offer

Brian Farrell, CEO of Kepak Foods

Kepak Group acquires Summit Foods to expand convenience offer

Kepak Group has announced the acquisition of Summit Foods, a UK-based company specialising in chilled and frozen convenience foods. With annual revenues of £24 million and a team of 200 employees, Summit Foods is an established player in the UK’s convenience food sector. The acquisition, is part of Kepak’s strategic plan to further grow its food business organically and via acquisition.

“We are pleased to welcome Summit Foods to the Kepak Group," said Brian Farrell, CEO of Kepak Foods. "This acquisition aligns with our growth strategy, developing our presence in the UK convenience and out-of-home food channels. Summit's portfolio of fresher for longer sandwiches, chilled and frozen meals & snacks complements our existing micro snacking offerings and allows us to deepen our presence across these markets”.

Keep ReadingShow less