Skip to content
Search
AI Powered
Latest Stories

Nestle bid to trademark Nespresso capsule fails

Nestle bid to trademark Nespresso capsule fails
Nespresso capsules (Andreas Rentz/Getty Images/File Photo)
Getty Images

The shape of Nespresso capsules cannot be protected by trademark law, Switzerland's highest court determined Tuesday, ending a long-running battle for the Swiss food giant Nestle.

The Federal Supreme Court ruled that a shape cannot be registered as a trademark if it has to be used by a competitor wishing to market a similar product.


"We are surprised and disappointed by the decision of the Federal Supreme Court," a Nespresso spokeswoman told AFP.

"However, we accept the ruling and will continue to concentrate on offering innovative, high-quality products to all our customers."

Nestle, one of the world's biggest food companies, is based in Vevey in Switzerland's western Vaud canton.

In September 2011, Nestle and its Nespresso branch took legal action in Vaud to ban the sale of capsules produced by the Ethical Coffee company.

That firm - which went bankrupt in 2018 - had developed a capsule similar in shape to the Nespresso original and compatible with the brand's machines.

Rather than being made from aluminium, its capsules were made from plant fibres and biodegradable starch. They were sold in France and Switzerland from the early 2010s.

The Vaud cantonal courts rejected the request for a ban and found the trademark issued by the Swiss Federal Institute of Intellectual Property to be invalid.

Swiss trademark law grants protection for 10 years, renewable indefinitely.

But Nestle, unhappy with the Vaud cantonal court's decision, appealed to the Federal Supreme Court.

The top national court's very detailed ruling contained technical drawings of real or imagined capsules, photos of competing capsules and also considerations on what makes for a quality cup of coffee.

The court found that the external dimensions of a Nespresso capsule, the angles of its conical shape, the top and the internal capacity had been developed to guarantee optimal functioning in the Nespresso coffee machine capsule compartment.

Insofar as competitors have to come to terms with these parameters, they do not have much room for manoeuvre, the court determined.

It emphasised that alternative capsules have a shape very similar to Nespresso ones, but found they differ slightly. It also found Nespresso capsules were no different in the minds of consumers.

More for you

muller clear pots

Müller converts Corner yogurt pots to clear plastic to reduce environmental impact

Müller Yogurt & Desserts said it is converting its iconic Corner yogurt pots from white to clear plastic, as the business works to halve the environmental impact of its packaging by 2030.

The majority of Müller Corner and Müller Bliss Corner yogurt pots have already converted, with the remaining volume taking place by the end of 2024.

Keep ReadingShow less
Zoa Energy Drinks

A view of Zoa Energy Drinks during the Food Network New York City Wine & Food Festival on October 14, 2023 in New York City

Photo by Rob Kim/Getty Images for NYCWFF

Molson Coors takes majority stake in Dwayne Johnson’s Zoa Energy brand

Molson Coors Beverage Company on Thursday announced that it is taking a majority ownership stake in Zoa, the better-for-you energy brand co-founded by Dwayne ‘The Rock’ Johnson, Dany Garcia, Dave Rienzi and John Shulman.

Molson Coors said taking a majority stake will allow it to lead the entirety of Zoa’s marketing, retail and direct-to-consumer sales and development. The deal represents one piece of Molson Coors’ strategic ambition to expand its total beverage portfolio.

Keep ReadingShow less
Londoners expected to spend average '£352 on Christmas lunch'
iStock image

Londoners expected to spend average '£352 on Christmas lunch'

Londoners are expected to spend an average of £352 on ingredients for Christmas lunch, festive snacks and nibbles, and all their drinks (both alcoholic and not) for the festive period, forecasts a new survey.

According to the survey of 2,000 Brits conducted by Very, Londoners are planning on spending more than £930 in preparation for Christmas this year, more than any other region in the country. The biggest spend Londoners will make is on food, expected to spend an average of £352 on ingredients for Christmas lunch, festive snacks and nibbles, and all their drinks (both alcoholic and not) for the festive period.

Keep ReadingShow less
Illicit goods seized in Oswaldtwistle

Some of the illicit goods seized in Oswaldtwistle

Photo: Lancashire County Council

Illegal tobacco and vapes worth £1.6 million seized in Lancashire

Huge amounts of counterfeit and illicit vapes, cigarettes and hand rolling tobacco cigarettes worth over £1.6million were seized in Lancashire late last month.

In one of the biggest Trading Standards seizures in Hyndburn to date, around 100,000 packs of illegal cigarettes and hand rolling tobacco, and hundreds of illegal non-regulation vapes, with a combined retail value of over £1.6million, were seized on 30 October in a joint operation with HMRC and Lancashire Constabulary from an empty trade premises next to a shop in Oswaldtwistle.

Keep ReadingShow less
Greenwashing
Photo: iStock

CMA closes investigation into Unilever’s ‘green’ claims, cites positive changes in industry

The Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has on Wednesday announced the closure of its investigation into Unilever's environmental claims, noting the progress made by both Unilever and the broader fast-moving consumer goods (FMCG) sector in ensuring transparent green marketing.

The decision comes after the CMA observed positive changes in Unilever’s product claims and the wider impact of its Green Claims Code, which has encouraged businesses to accurately promote their environmental credentials.

Keep ReadingShow less