Skip to content
Search
AI Powered
Latest Stories

Post Office was ‘sabotaging our efforts to seek truth’

Post Office was ‘sabotaging our efforts to seek truth’
Former Post Office chief executive Paula Vennells arrives on her third day of testifying at the Post Office inquiry on May 24, 2024 in London, England. (Photo by Carl Court/Getty Images)

Former Post Office top brass Paula Vennells “frequently and consistently” attempted to “steer” investigators away from looking at wrongful Horizon convictions, an independent forensic accountant, told the Post Office inquiry today (18), suggesting that there was "possibly a criminal conspiracy" at the Post Office.

Ian Henderson was one of the two forensic accountants from Second Sight paid by Post Office (POL) to review sub-postmaster convictions involving Horizon in 2012. Vennells, the former Post Office chief executive, was already in her role when Second Sight began its inquiry in mid-2012.


During the hearing, Henderson revealed how he had signed a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) with the Post Office and claimed he later faced a "thinly veiled threat" from the company's then head of legal Chris Aujard "to bankrupt me if I continued causing trouble".

A 2013 interim report produced by Henderson and his colleague Ron Warmington identified two bugs in the Horizon system that caused problems for 76 branches. The forensic accountants were sacked in 2015, and Henderson said he believed they were dismissed because they were “getting too close to the truth”.

He told the inquiry he felt the Post Office was "constantly sabotaging our efforts to seek the truth irrespective of the consequences".

During the hearing today, counsel to the inquiry Jason Beer KC asked, "What had happened to the 'shared desire to seek the truth irrespective of the consequences?'"

Henderson replied, "I think we'd moved on from that. I'd formed the view that quite early on in the process, Post Office was getting advice from external lawyers about the financial consequences of what we were finding - the fact that they might be looking at very material amounts of compensation."

He added, "It was very clear that Post Office senior management were very concerned about the public perception, the brand image - I mean, Paula Vennells in meetings was very open about it. She was determined to promote the brand of Post Office.

"By February 2015, I no longer had confidence that POL was taking our concerns seriously or dealing with them in an appropriate manner.

"I felt we were dealing with a cover-up by POL and possibly a criminal conspiracy. I was concerned about the various threats that had been made to me by POL concerning alleged breaches of my NDA and my duties of confidentiality. One of the reasons it was challenging was that POL would say one thing in public, and then do something different in private.

"An example of this was Paula Vennells' statement to the Parliamentary Select Committee in February 2015, that our work had found 'no evidence of miscarriages of justice' and 'it was important that we surface any miscarriages of justice'.

"Paula Vennells frequently and consistently attempted to steer Second Sight away from investigating potential miscarriages of justice. When I first met Paula Vennells, she told me that POL was the nation's most trusted brand with a history of over 400 years.

"As our work continued, I increasingly formed the view that because of this history, POL somehow felt it was above the law. I formed the view that POL was constantly sabotaging our efforts to seek the truth irrespective of the consequences.

"Requests for documents were either ignored or responses were excessively delayed. Unjustified claims of legal professional privilege were used to justify withholding documents from us."

More than 900 branch workers were wrongfully prosecuted as a result of faulty Horizon software, which saw shortfalls incorrectly recorded on their accounts.

In her own evidence to the inquiry last month, Vennells said she had been perhaps "too trusting" of people around her when it came to getting to the truth about miscarriages of justice.

More for you

Volumatic welcomes new FCA rules safeguarding access to cash

Volumatic welcomes new FCA rules safeguarding access to cash

As industry leaders is cash handling, Volumatic has long supported the use of cash and the importance of maintaining access to cash for both consumers and businesses. The company recognises the importance of the new set of rules created by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) two months ago, to safeguard access to cash for businesses and consumers across the UK.

Since introduction, the new rules are intended to ensure that individuals and businesses who rely on cash can continue to access it and the outcome has already sparked the creation of 15 new banking hubs across the UK, including one in Scotland, with many more to follow.

Keep ReadingShow less
Jisp unveils new NPD service

Jisp unveils new NPD service

Retail technology company Jisp has launched an NPD service as part of its new Direct to Retailer business unit.

The new NPD service will allow brands to launch or trial new products in a guaranteed number of convenience store locations, with on the ground review of execution by Jisp’s retail growth manager team, and performance data and insights deliverable through its scanning technology and back-office systems.

Keep ReadingShow less
Tesco launches price cuts in Express convenience stores
File image of Tesco Express

Tesco launches price cuts in Express convenience stores

Tesco is slashing the price of more than 222 own-brand and branded products in its Express convenience stores.

Essentials including milk, bread, pasta and coffee are included in the lines which have been reduced in price by an average of more than 10 per cent at Tesco Express stores. The retail giant has made more than 2,800 price cuts across stores in recent months. With 2,048 of convenience stores at the end of the 2023-24 financial year, Tesco aims to benefit hundreds of thousands of customers from the cheaper deals.

Keep ReadingShow less
vape and cigarette
Photo: iStock

One in five ex-smokers in England now vape, study finds


Summary
1. One in five people who have successfully quit smoking in England currently vape, with an estimated 2.2 million individuals using e-cigarettes as a smoking cessation tool.
2. The increase in vaping among ex-smokers is largely driven by the use of e-cigarettes in quit attempts, with a rise in vaping uptake among people who had previously quit smoking for many years before taking up vaping.
3. While vaping may be a less harmful option compared to smoking, there are concerns about the potential long-term implications of vaping on relapse risk and nicotine addiction. Further research is needed to assess the impact of vaping on smoking cessation outcomes.


Keep ReadingShow less
Bira engages with Treasury on Budget fallout, business rate reform
(Photo by Christopher Furlong/Getty Images)
Getty Images

Bira engages with Treasury on Budget fallout, business rate reform

Independent retailers association Bira has held a meeting with members of the Treasury team to discuss concerns following its robust response to the Government’s recent Budget announcement.

The Budget, labelled by Bira as "devastating" for independent retailers, was met with widespread indignation from Bira members.

Keep ReadingShow less