Skip to content
Search
AI Powered
Latest Stories

Retail industry reacts to budget with scepticism, general dismay

Immediate reaction to Chancellor Rachel Reeves’s first budget has not been positive.

Our regular columnist, CEO of the British Independent Retailers Association (BIRA), Andrew Goodacre, condemned the budget out of hand, calling it, “Without doubt the worst for independent retailers I have seen in my time representing the sector. The government's actions today show complete disregard for the thousands of hard-working shop owners who form the backbone of our high streets.”


He said, "This Budget betrays every independent retailer who has fought to keep their business alive through recent challenges. It's not just disappointing – it's potentially catastrophic for Britain's high streets."

There were crumbs, or rather drops, of comfort. Reeves made much of the fact that there is a penny off a pint of beer (thereby saving nearly a shilling when getting drunk), although Simon Shelbourn, Chief Financial Officer for employee-owned Kingsland Drinks pointed out that while publicans might be feeling optimistic, retailers are drinking the dregs of good fortune:

“Further taxing non-draft alcohol hurts everyone; Whilst the government is working hard to plug the hole in the country’s finances, the consumer is being further penalised despite already bearing the weight of the cost-of-living crisis, and much of the drinks industry will once again have to prove its resilience despite being positioned to drive economic growth.

He said that the move to wallop bottled beer is damaging to the industry and a setback to firms across the board “who have worked tirelessly in recent years to withstand relentless taxation in the toughest of trading conditions.”

James Lowman, CEO of the Association of Convenience Stores (ACS), quickly drew up a list of disappointments, which he apostrophized as “two-thirds of a billion pounds to the direct cost base of the UK’s local shops” – although he pointed out that, “The smallest retailers, with low NICs bills and lower rateable values for their shops, will benefit from the welcome increase in the employment allowance and the retention of 40% of the retail business rates relief.”

Lowman was enthusiastic about the Chancellor’s commitment to tackling shop theft, but stressed that his long-disillusioned members “are interested only in action and in crime against their stores and their colleagues being tackled effectively.” – in other words, we’ll believe it when we see it.

The Institute of Economic Affairs predictably criticised Reeves on ideological grounds, with Tom Clougherty, Executive Director, stating, “The Government came into office promising to prioritise growth. But the reality of their first Budget – heavier burdens on business and more borrowing for public sector capital spending – does not inspire much confidence in their approach.”

He added, more in anger than sorrow: “Coming alongside an inflation-busting increase in the minimum wage and heavy-handed changes to employment law, higher employer National Insurance Contributions will be a bitter pill for firms to swallow. Businesses will see their costs rise and it will be workers who pay the price – in the form of lower wages, reduced benefits, and fewer job opportunities. The idea that this Budget does not increase taxes on workers is an economic fantasy.”

The Fed’s National President, Mo Razzaq, welcomed the alleged “crackdown on crime” and the end of the infamous “£200 rule”, but also echoed the sentiment that a higher minimum wage will lead directly to fewer retail establishments:

“A bigger-than-expected rise to the national living wage to £12.21 an hour from April 2025 is a step too far for hard-pressed small businesses,” he opined.

“As well as paying our staff more in wages, we must pay more in national insurance and pension costs, at a time when many of our other costs, including energy, are rising. There is no easy way for small retailers to combat these increases. As so many of the products that convenience store owners are price marked, we cannot pass these costs onto our customers.

“The only solution available to independent shop owners is to reduce staff hours and staff numbers and, somehow, take on even more hours ourselves.”

Pleasures are being penalised, some would say as usual. Nuno Teles, Managing Director of Diageo GB, felt betrayed by increased taxes on spirits – which will take the minimum tax burden on a bottle of Scotch Whisky above £12 for the first time – saying, “On the campaign trail, Keir Starmer pledged to ‘back the Scotch whisky industry to the hilt’. Instead, the Government has broken this promise and slammed even more duty on spirits. This betrayal will leave a bitter taste for drinkers and pubs while jeopardising jobs and investment across Scotland.”

Speaking of Scotland, the MD of the Scottish Licensed Trade Association (SLTA), Colin Wilkinson, although he welcomed the 40 per cent relief on business rates for retail, leisure and hospitality (up to a cap of £25,000), spoke of a “triple blow of an increase in the NLW, risen by 50 per cent in five years, increased employer National Insurance contributions and a 50 per cent reduction in the threshold level for Employer National Insurance contributions.

“These will be yet another fiscal burden for all businesses and will restrict investment, restrict growth and increase the risk of job losses,” he said. “As a staff-intensive sector, many in the licensed hospitality industry will now be questioning whether or not they can even maintain their current staffing levels.”

Mo Razzaq also raised the alarm at the tobacco and next gen gantry, arguing that byputting duty up by 10 per cent on hand-rolling tobacco, a flat rate duty on all vaping liquids, a one-off increase in tobacco duty in line with RPI “were further blows to independent retailers”.

He pointed out something that we have been talking about until blue in the face recently: “When tobacco prices rise, more smokers are lured to the illicit market, which damages the business of legitimate retailers and damages communities. The government needs to do more to tackle the illicit market to better protect the livelihoods of members who legitimately sell tobacco.”

The last word should go to Mike Salem, the UK Country Associate for the Consumer Choice Center (CCC), who said that “Reeves wants to punish consumers for spending their own money, and these taxes were never really about public health or nudging, but a cash grab from hard-working British people.”

He called the Budget an economic "Reeversal".

More for you

Post Office cash deposits and withdrawals
Post Office, DPD partners to rollout ‘Click and Collect’ services
Post Office, DPD partners to rollout ‘Click and Collect’ services

Parliament to launch inquiry into Post Office Horizon scandal compensation delays

Parliament is to launch an inquiry into delays in compensation settlements for sub postmasters affected by the Horizon scandal.

The newly-formed Business and Trade Select Committee will call ministers, subpostmasters and their lawyers to give evidence next week with a second session to follow in mid-November. The Committee’s chair, Liam Byrne MP told ITV News that there was “definitely a delay” in people coming forward for payment.

Keep ReadingShow less
Bacup Wine and Convenience shop, 34 Burnley Road, Bacup.

Bacup Wine and Convenience shop, 34 Burnley Road, Bacup.

Robbie MacDonald via LDRS

Shop’s licence bid rejected over illegal vapes and ‘no regard’ for children’s safety

A Rossendale shop has had a licence bid rejected after repeatedly selling vapes to children and having illegal products on its premises.

Management at the Ibra Superstore at 34 Burnley Road, Bacup, have shown ‘no regard’ for children’s protection and safety, and have insufficient controls for licensing, Rossendale councillors have ruled.

Keep ReadingShow less
SPAR retailer hits target to secure £100,000 free stock from James Hall

SPAR retailer hits target to secure £100,000 free stock from James Hall

SPAR North of England retailer Dara Singh Randhawa’s family store has been awarded £100,000 of free stock after hitting all his targets since moving to the symbol.

Dara and his family, who have their SPAR store in Patrington in the East Riding of Yorkshire, joined SPAR through its association with James Hall & Co. Ltd in August 2023 having taken the decision to maximise the store’s potential.

Keep ReadingShow less
Pound Sterling bank notes
iStock

National Living Wage to increase to £12.21 in April 2025

The government has on Wednesday announced its acceptance of the Low Pay Commission’s (LPC) recommendations on the rates of the National Minimum Wage (NMW), including the National Living Wage (NLW).

The rates which will apply from 1 April 2025 are as follows:

Keep ReadingShow less
National President Mo Razzaq 2024 serious 1 1
Fed National President Mo Razzaq

Indies: It’s criminal police and government turn blind eye to shoplifting

Independent retailers are demanding tougher police action, more bobbies on the beat and harsher punishments as shoplifting levels reach an all-time high, a new survey reveals.

A whopping ninety-one per cent of respondents to a survey conducted by the Federation of Independent Retailers (the Fed) called for more police patrols on streets, while a similar number - 90 per cent - said that shoplifters should be handed harsher sentences.

Seven out of 10 respondents (72 per cent) said their stores had experienced shoplifting, break ins and damage to property, while they and their staff had been physically or verbally threatened.

Just under half of respondents (47 per cent) said they and their employees had been threatened or had suffered abuse and violence when asking for proof of age ahead of selling an age-restricted product.

Forty-four per cent reported that they and their staff had faced abuse or violence because they had refused to make a proxy sale – selling an age restricted product to a customer buying for a minor.

The results of the Fed’s survey came as new figures from the Office of National Statistics revealed that shoplifting was at a record high, with almost half a million offences recorded last year.

According to the ONS, 469,788 offences were logged by forces in the year to June 2024 – a 29 per cent increase on the previous 12 months.

The ONS added that this figure was the highest since records began – in March 2003.

“Inadequate responses from the police and a slap on the wrist for offenders means that shoplifting is soaring, and offenders are becoming more aggressive and brazen,” said Fed National President Mo Razzaq.

“From the responses we received, it is clear that real action is needed by police, by courts and by the government to stem the overwhelming tide of crime against retailers and their staff. Everyone deserves to feel safe at work and for their businesses to be protected against criminals.

“Fed members are also sending a clear message that one of the catalysts for verbal and physical abuse in stores is asking for proof of age before selling an age restricted product. If the government presses ahead with its plans to phase out smoking and vaping through a progressive ban to gradually end the sale of tobacco products across the country, independent retailers will be subject to even greater levels of violence, abuse and theft.”

Calling for action from the government and not just words, Mr Razzaq continued: “Without effective deterrent, criminals and opportunistic members of the public will continue to commit crimes.”

According to Ministry of Justice statistics, during the year to March 2024, 431 fines were handed out for retail theft under £100, while Home Office statistics for the same period show that 2,252 cautions were accepted for shoplifting.